There are so many to choose from, and no idea which one[s] will be best. [to my american-ish tastes?]
I mean, I am down to try more unusual food, but once at Go Go Cafe, we ordered the black bean catfish, and rather than fillets, it was the whole fish, chopped up, eyeballs and all. And...we don't eat those parts, really... ;p (and we love Go Go otherwise--late night; combo specials=good)

Suggestions in the 30-something Avenues especially welcome!
Also the best of the ones from other areas [ie Ocean] that hang delivery ads on doors.